Language as a Catalyst: Does Bilingualism Promote Growth Mindset?
This quantitative study investigated the differences in growth mindset levels between bilingual and monolingual adults, as assessed by the Dweck Mindset Instrument (DMI). Theoretical studies have indicated that bilingualism may improve cognitive flexibility, possibly fostering growth-oriented beliefs; however, empirical research directly connecting bilingualism and mindset is scarce. This study, informed by Dweck’s implicit theory of intelligence and Bandura’s social cognitive framework, examined the correlation between language status and perceptions regarding the malleability of intelligence and talent. A total of 170 adults living in the United States (85 monolingual and 85 bilingual) completed a demographic questionnaire and the 16-item DMI. Three independent samples t tests were conducted to compare monolingual and bilingual participants regarding (a) overall mindset, (b) intelligence-related items, and (c) talent-related items. The results indicated no statistically significant differences between monolinguals and bilinguals in any of the three mindset scores, with effect sizes being negligible across all analyses. A sensitivity analysis excluding responses identified as low-quality produced identical patterns of nonsignificant results. The findings suggest that bilingualism by itself does not correlate with an elevated growth mindset in adults. The findings expand current discussions on the cognitive and motivational aspects of bilingualism and emphasize the importance of environmental and educational influences, rather than solely language background, in shaping individuals’ beliefs about intelligence. The implications for educators and suggestions for future research are examined.
Keywords: growth mindset, bilingualism, monolingualism, Dweck Mindset Instrument, implicit theories of intelligence